Key Quote
“"I resisted all the way: a new thing for me"”
Jane Eyre (narrator) · Chapter 2
Focus: “resisted”
Young Jane's first act of physical resistance — fighting back against John Reed — marks the birth of her defiant identity, a 'new thing' that will define her entire life.
Technique 1 — DECLARATIVE SIMPLICITY / TRANSFORMATIVE MOMENT
The sentence is grammatically simple — subject ('I'), verb ('resisted'), qualifier ('all the way') — but its simplicity belies its significance. This is a transformative moment (an event that fundamentally changes a character's trajectory): Jane moves from passive endurance to active resistance. The word 'resisted' is active, physical, and forceful — a child claiming her body as a site of agency.
The appositional phrase — 'a new thing for me' — adds retrospective commentary: the narrator acknowledges that resistance is unprecedented (never done before) in her experience. This tiny confession reveals how completely Jane had previously accepted her subordination. The 'new thing' is not just an action but a new self — a Jane who pushes back.
Key Words
RAD — PROGRESS
This is Jane's first progression — the foundational act from which all subsequent growth follows. Before this moment, Jane endured; after it, she resists. The progression is physical before it is intellectual: Jane's body rebels before her mind can articulate why. Brontë shows that liberation begins not with theory but with the visceral refusal to be hurt any longer.
Key Words
Technique 2 — COLON AS AWAKENING
The colon — 'I resisted all the way: a new thing for me' — separates action from reflection, body from mind. Before the colon, Jane acts; after it, she understands. The colon marks the birth of self-consciousness (awareness of oneself as an acting agent): Jane does not merely resist but recognises that she is resisting. This double consciousness — acting AND observing oneself act — is what distinguishes Jane from the mere victim she was before.
The phrase 'for me' is quietly devastating: resistance is 'new' for JANE but presumably normal for those who have power. The qualifier reveals how deeply gendered and classed resistance is — some people resist naturally (the privileged); for others (poor orphan girls), resistance is a revolutionary act. 'For me' locates the significance in Jane's specific social position.
Key Words
Context (AO3)
CHILD DISCIPLINE IN VICTORIAN ENGLAND
Victorian children — especially dependants like orphans — were expected to endure corporal punishment (physical discipline) without resistance. Jane's physical fight-back against John Reed violates every expectation of childhood obedience, female passivity, and social deference to one's 'betters.'
THE BODY POLITIC
Jane's resistance is physical before it is political — she uses her body as a weapon before she uses her voice. This reflects a truth about oppression: bodies are disciplined before minds, and liberation often begins with the body's refusal to comply.
Key Words
WOW — SUBJUGATED KNOWLEDGE (Foucault)
Foucault's concept of subjugated knowledge — ways of knowing that are suppressed or delegitimised by dominant power structures — illuminates Jane's 'new thing.' The knowledge that resistance is possible has been suppressed in Jane's world: orphans don't fight back, girls don't hit boys, the poor don't challenge the rich. Jane's resistance is an eruption of subjugated knowledge into the dominant order — the discovery that the rules she has obeyed are not natural laws but human constructions that can be broken. Foucault argues that power maintains itself partly by making resistance seem impossible or unthinkable. Jane's 'new thing' is new precisely because the power structure has made it unthinkable. By thinking — and doing — the unthinkable, Jane cracks the system's facade of naturalness and reveals it as contingent (dependent on circumstances, not inevitable). Every subsequent act of resistance in the novel flows from this first crack.
Key Words